Kristan Hawkins, president of Students for Life of America, posted a video to Instagram on March 23. The caption read: "Guess what we are doing? Ordering abortion pills undercover? Yep. Stay tuned."
Seven months later, she's being sued for $460,000 — under a Texas law designed to stop illegal abortion pill trafficking.
The plaintiff is Maria Puerto, a pseudonymous 26-year-old mother of one- and three-year-old children, represented by Amplify Legal — the litigation arm of Abortion in America, an organization founded by the late Cecile Richards of Planned Parenthood fame. The lawsuit, filed October 13, invokes HB 7, the Texas Women and Child Protection Act, which allows private citizens to bring civil enforcement actions against anyone who mails, transports, delivers, prescribes, or provides abortion-inducing drugs in Texas.
The law was built to go after abortion pill distributors. Puerto's lawyers are using it to go after the people who exposed the distribution.
HB 7 sets a minimum of $100,000 in damages per violation, plus attorney fees. Puerto is claiming at least four violations. Under the law's relator provision — borrowed from the federal False Claims Act — the private citizen who brings the suit keeps $10,000 per violation, with the remainder going to a designated organization. In this case, that would be Jane's Due Process, an abortion-access group.
So the money trail runs from a pro-life investigation, through a pro-life law, into the accounts of an abortion-access nonprofit. The legal judo is almost elegant.
Peter Breen, a defense lawyer with the Thomas More Society, called the suit "a patently meritless attempt to silence and cover up the truth that out-of-state interests are flooding Texas with abortion pills." Breen argued that Hawkins and her team were doing investigative journalism — gathering evidence of illegal trafficking and sharing it publicly, activity the First Amendment protects.
Breen also noted that Puerto's own complaint undercuts the case. "Wrote our defense for us," he said. HB 7 specifically exempts women who use or obtain pills for their own personal use. Puerto isn't being targeted. She was never at legal risk from the law she's now wielding.
Hawkins, through her lawyers, framed the absurdity: "Noticing the obvious — abortion pills can be illegally trafficked — is like going after the person reporting a fire instead of the arsonist."
The defendants' answer was filed November 9. Alongside Hawkins, the suit names SFLA spokesperson Lydia Taylor Davis, campus tour manager Jamie Curry, and Texas regional coordinator Megan Roos. State GOP Representative Briscoe Cain is also serving as defense counsel, as reported by Just The News.
Texas built the private enforcement model with SB 8 five years ago — the near-total abortion ban that let citizens sue providers instead of relying on prosecutors. It was controversial then. The left called it vigilante justice, bounty hunting, an end-run around Roe. Now the same mechanism is being turned around by the people who opposed it, aimed at the people who championed it, to punish them for catching illegal activity the law was written to stop.
The fire is still burning. The lawsuit targets the people who called it in.
